Lesson 4: The Plagues
4.2 Who Hardened Pharaohβs Heart?
A Hardened Heart β Choosing Against God’s Grace
………………………………………………………………….
Introduction
The story of the Exodus from Egypt is powerful, challenging, and full of spiritual principles. But one central question often leads to debate: Who hardened Pharaohβs heart?
Was it God? Or Pharaoh himself?
The answer touches on deep topics like Godβs sovereignty, human free will, and how we deal with light and truth.
………………………………………………………………….
Bible Study
Introduction: An Uncomfortable Question
Few topics in the Old Testament have triggered as much discussion as the question of Pharaohβs hardened heart.
How can God harden a heartβand then punish the person for their decisions?
Does that mean Pharaoh had no real choice?
Or was it rather his own attitude that led to a hardened heartβand God merely allowed or reinforced it?
This study invites you to explore the tension between God’s sovereignty and human responsibilityβbiblically, clearly, and understandably.
1. Observation from the Biblical Text: Two Statements β One Complete Picture
Looking at all the passages, the following becomes clear:
God hardened Pharaohβs heart:
-
Exodus 4:21
-
Exodus 7:3
-
Exodus 9:12
-
Exodus 10:1, 20, 27
-
Exodus 11:10
-
Exodus 14:4, 8
-
Romans 9:17β18
Pharaoh hardened his own heart:
-
Exodus 7:13β14, 22
-
Exodus 8:15, 19, 32
-
Exodus 9:7, 34β35
Observation:
In the first five plagues, Pharaoh is the active party. He rejects.
From the sixth plague onward, God initiates the hardening.
This order is crucial for our understanding.
2. Interpretation: What Does βHardenβ Even Mean?
The Hebrew word for βhardenβ (chazaq β ΧΦΈΧΦ·Χ§) also means to strengthen, make firm, hold fast.
This means: God did not override Pharaohβs decision but confirmed it. He allowed Pharaoh to continue on his chosen pathβwith all its consequences.
Compare this with Romans 1:24β28:
There it says that God βgave them overβ because they refused to acknowledge Him.
God does not actively do evilβbut He respects human freedom so deeply that He allows a person to walk a destructive path if they persist.
3. Theological Parallels
Example 1: King Saul
Saul was also abandoned by the Spirit of God after repeatedly disobeying Godβs clear commands (1 Samuel 16:14).
He wasnβt without willβbut his heart grew hard through disobedience.
Example 2: Judas Iscariot
Judas lived near Jesus, heard His words, saw miraclesβand still chose against Him.
In the end, βSatan entered himβ (Luke 22:3).
But even here: The door didnβt slam shut suddenlyβit was closed step by step.
4. The Purpose of the Plagues β Conversion, Not Destruction
God wanted Pharaoh to come to understandingβnot to be broken.
The plagues were targeted warnings, signs of Godβs power, but also opportunities for repentance (cf. Exodus 9:14β16).
Repeatedly, God said through Moses: βLet my people go.β
With each refusal, Pharaohβs heart became more closedβnot because God darkened it, but because light that is not accepted leads to hardening.
Like the hot sun:
-
Butter melts.
-
Clay hardens.
The sun is the sameβthe reaction depends on the material.
5. Summary of Biblical Findings
-
Pharaoh had a free will.
-
God respected that willβHe didnβt manipulate it.
-
The hardening was the result of conscious decisions, not Godβs arbitrariness.
-
Godβs statement in Exodus 4:21 was not carried out arbitrarily, but in harmony with Pharaohβs free will.
6. Spiritual Principles
-
Godβs patience has a purpose: repentance. But those who reject it risk hardening.
-
Resistance to truth makes the heart hard.
-
Free will also means responsibility.
-
God is justβeven when He acts sovereignly.
-
Hardening is not a punishmentβit is often a consequence.
7. Application in Daily Life
-
How do I respond to Godβs voice in my life?
-
Where might I be ignoring impulses from Godβs Word?
-
Do I become soft or hard when God corrects me?
-
Do I believe my heart cannot change? Or am I open to Godβs work?
Every person lives in this tension. Our reaction to Godβs Word determines whether we growβor become hardened.
Conclusion
The story of Pharaoh does not show arbitrary action by God.
It shows how deep and serious it is to continually ignore Godβs Word.
God wants to saveβbut He does not force.
He actsβbut He respects our decisions.
Those who are open receive more light.
Those who close off become hard.
The human heart remains the keyβeven today.
………………………………………………………………….
Answers to the Questions
Question 1: Who hardened Pharaohβs heart β God or Pharaoh himself?
The biblical texts in Exodus mention both: God and Pharaoh are described as agents in the hardening process. But the sequence and context help us understand this tension better.
Initially, in the first five plagues (e.g., Exodus 7β9), it is Pharaoh who hardens his heart. It says: βPharaohβs heart remained hardβ or βPharaoh hardened his heart.β
This means: Pharaoh acted willfully and consciously against Godβs command. He had the ability to chooseβand he chose disobedience and opposition to Godβs people.
From the sixth plague onward, the description changes: now it says God hardened Pharaohβs heart (e.g., Exodus 9:12).
This is not a contradiction. It shows that God confirms a decision that a person makes repeatedly. He gives them over to their own waysβa principle Paul describes several times in Romans 1:24β28 (βTherefore God gave them overβ¦β).
God did not plant evil in Pharaohβs heart. He did not manipulateβbut responded to repeated, deliberate decisions with a divine consequence.
Godβs goal through the plagues was not destructionβbut repentance, insight, and justice.
But Pharaoh did not use his freedom for good, but for rebellion.
God took him seriously in that decision, confirmed it, and let him experience the consequences of his choice.
Question 2: What free-will decision(s) will you make in the coming days? If you know what the right decision is, how can you prepare to make it?
Each of us regularly faces decisions that may not seem earth-shatteringβbut they shape our hearts:
-
Will I be faithful to the truth todayβeven if itβs uncomfortable?
-
Will I stand up against pressure and peer influenceβor conform?
-
Will I take Godβs voice seriouslyβor ignore it?
Maybe your next decision involves a conversation where you need clarityβor the question of whether you truly prioritize time with God.
Maybe it’s about whether you’re willing to forgiveβor choose to hold a grudge.
Preparing for right decisions begins in the heart:
-
Spending time with God in prayer
-
Listening to His Word
-
Being honest about your weaknesses
-
Being willing to be corrected
The story of Pharaoh reminds us:
A person doesnβt become hardened overnight. It begins with small stepsβwith the first βnoβ to God.
But just as easily, it can begin with a humble βyesβ that softens the heart.
Those who daily open their hearts to God will be ready in decisive momentsβto do what is right. Not out of pressure, but out of conviction.
………………………………………………………………….
Spiritual Principles
-
Godβs light demands a response. Ignoring it leads to inner dullness.
-
Free will remainsβbut repeated disobedience can lead to hardening.
-
God forces no oneβbut He allows us to feel the consequences of our choices.
-
Resistance to God hardens the heartβacceptance softens it.
-
Responsibility grows with understanding.
…………………………………………………………………
Application for Daily Life
-
Watch out for the βsmall hardeningsβ of your heartβwhere you ignore Godβs voice.
-
Consciously make a decision today for what is rightβeven if itβs inconvenient.
-
Ask God for a soft heart and a humble attitude.
-
Observe how you respond to spiritual impulsesβdo you avoid them or open up?
………………………………………………………………….
Conclusion
The story of Pharaoh shows:
God doesnβt control our heartsβwe choose whether they become soft or hard.
God reaches outβbut He doesnβt force.
If we keep saying no, God lets us go our own wayβwith all its consequences.
But if we open up, He can shape and heal our hearts.
………………………………………………………………….
Thought of the Day
βGodβs truth does not harden our heartsβbut our resistance to it does.β
………………………………………………………………….
Illustration β The Judgeβs Decision
A modern story about the heart, freedom, and Godβs call
Chapter 1: The Call of Responsibility
Hartsville, Georgia. The summer was oppressively hot, the fields dryβand the hearts of people often just as hardened.
Judge Raymond Carter was considered βreliable,β but distant. Heβd headed the district court for years.
Faith? That was something from his youthβconnected to hymns in the Baptist church and his devout motherβs smile.
But today, a case lay on his desk that wouldnβt let go of him.
Chapter 2: A Teacher, A Prayer, A Conflict
David White, a teacher at the local high school, had prayed with a student during breakβquietly, respectfully.
The student was worried about his sick mother. The prayer was spontaneous.
But the school administration saw it as a violation of neutrality and dismissed him.
David suedβand the case landed on Judge Carterβs desk.
The media picked it up. A simple prayer became a political issue.
Chapter 3: The Voice of the Past
After the first hearing, Pastor Josephβan old friend from youthβshowed up in Carterβs office uninvited.
βYou know whatβs right,β he said calmly.
βI know whatβs politically smart,β Carter replied.
But that night, Carter heard a sermon on the radio. The preacher spoke about Pharaoh:
βGod hardened his heartβbut only after Pharaoh had done it himself again and again.β
Carter couldnβt sleep.
Chapter 4: Pressure From All Sides
Weeks passed. Activists, school boards, politiciansβeveryone had an opinion.
A ruling in Davidβs favor would bring criticism.
A rejection would be easier.
Carter felt it: his heart was hardeningβnot suddenly, but through many small choices.
Chapter 5: The Burning Document
The day of the ruling came. The decision was printed, ready to sign:
βClaim denied.β
His hand trembled.
Then he heard an inner voice:
βWhat good is your position if you lose your conviction?β
He put the pen down. Called his assistant. And said:
βChange the ruling. David will be reinstated.β
Chapter 6: The Price of Obedience
The headlines the next day were harsh. Some called him βoutdated,β βnaΓ―ve,β βreligiously blinded.β
But Carter felt peace.
He returned to the Baptist church after years. And at a prayer meeting, he whispered:
βLord, thank you for not giving up on my heart.β
Chapter 7: True Freedom
Carter knew: He may have lost political influenceβbut he had heard Godβs call while his heart was still soft.
And David? He returned to teaching. Not as a rebelβbut as a living witness that a simple prayer can move mountains.
Conclusion of the Story
As with Pharaoh, we see even today:
Hearts donβt become hard all at onceβbut through many small decisions against the conscience.
But Godβs grace is stronger.
As long as you can still hearβyou can still respond.